PDA

View Full Version : Who is better Singer: Britney spears, Jenny Beck, Christina Agulera


trunkks
04-15-2004, 01:44 PM
Christina agulera and Jenny Beck write and sing there songs. Jenny becks album "morneing rain" have many good songs on it. the song "i turn to you" Christina agulera is very good. Britney spears is a good singer but her best songs are from hjer first album. i like her video "i am a slave" but the song is not very good. who do you like?

WhammyBar
04-15-2004, 03:42 PM
uumm.....none of them! Christina Aguilera can sing, but she's needs to get better material. Britney Spears: ew. trashy trashy trashy.

LionelHutz
04-15-2004, 09:59 PM
Who the heck is Jenny Beck? I'm old! :( Britney can't have a song without huge amounts of electronic processing to cover up the fact that she can't sing.

WhammyBar
04-15-2004, 10:31 PM
I'm young and really in tune with music (although not really that kind) and I have no clue who Jenny Beck is. I also happen to think that all the electro crap on Briteny's new single, Toxic, is really good, but then she sings over it and ruins it. so they should get someone with a good voice to redo it, cus then it would rock my world.

silverbulletkc
04-16-2004, 08:03 AM
I think if all three of them quit their jobs and got other careers where they don't sing, it would be doing this world a great service.

Imp
04-16-2004, 08:46 AM
Hayley Westenra hands down...15 or 16 years old and natural...It's the song 'amazing grace'...and her voice is beautiful... (http://mcms-delivery.virtuebroadcasting.com/deliverMedia.asp?id=6DB2558E-0181-4D20-AED5-E1F4DE5815F4&embedded=1):D

Overdose
04-16-2004, 06:28 PM
SPICE GIRLS

WhammyBar
04-17-2004, 11:30 AM
I love the spice girls. me and my freinds dance on tables whenever they come on. at philly cheesteak places in North Carolina on vacation. hehe. they crack me up.

Mapper
04-19-2004, 04:38 PM
I hate them all, except Jennifer Beck who I didn't know existed, nor do I care if she is being compared to Christina Aguilera and Brittany Spears. Growl. Oh and Spice Girls? Rock on.

pna43
04-21-2004, 10:02 PM
If we put all three in a car and sent it careening over a cliff to the jagged rocks below, do you think they'd all hit one perfect note together?:rolleyes:

LionelHutz
04-22-2004, 11:22 AM
Probably not - but let's try it anyway!

silverbulletkc
04-22-2004, 11:38 AM
Even if they don't hit that perfect note, it's three less crappy, under-dressed singers to worry about

trunkks
04-23-2004, 02:08 PM
Originally posted by LionelHutz
Who the heck is Jenny Beck? I'm old! :( Britney can't have a song without huge amounts of electronic processing to cover up the fact that she can't sing.


Jenny beck are swedish pop singer

Inimitable
04-24-2004, 10:46 PM
I've never heard of Jenny Beck so between Britney and Christina... I think Christina is better.

Mapper
04-24-2004, 11:07 PM
Originally posted by pna43
If we put all three in a car and sent it careening over a cliff to the jagged rocks below, do you think they'd all hit one perfect note together?:rolleyes: LOL!!!! Yay!

M&Mdelite
04-25-2004, 11:21 PM
From your 3 choices, Christina definitely has the best voice.

Moonbeam
12-30-2004, 09:18 AM
Personally I don't think it's fair to compare Jenny Beck to Britney or Christina as her music isn't the same genre.....she writes folk/pop and acoustic stuff and shouldn't be compared to either....she's more like The Corrs and Sheryl Crow.....if you need to compare her music with something.

I'm no great fan of Britney or Christina, but I do admire people who write their own material, so it'd have to be Christina for me. Britneys new sound is pretty cool, but I do think she's trying a bit too hard to achieve a new image....she'll never be cool! :p

"Beautiful" was a really nice song....but I really don't like Christinas wailing....just stay on the note for ones!!! :D

Jenny has a nice, unique sound and I hope that she'll do well. I admire the fact that she plays guitar as well as sings and produces her own material....you go girl!!! :) I'm sure we'll see and hear more of her in the future....I hope so at least! The world doesn't need any more Britneys and Christinas....we need more serious, talented songwriters and musicians who can actually play and sing and who writes about important things...."Morning Rain" rocks!

Happy new year! :drinktoth

es347fan
12-30-2004, 10:13 AM
Not one of them are musicians. At best they're parrots singing to the tune of their overpaid agents. Not a one of them can carry a tune, all they have to offer is youth & boobs.

Moonbeam
12-30-2004, 01:58 PM
Originally posted by es347fan
Not one of them are musicians. At best they're parrots singing to the tune of their overpaid agents. Not a one of them can carry a tune, all they have to offer is youth & boobs.


Britney and Christina maybe, but it's hardly true about Jenny Beck. Have you even heard her music or ever seen a photo of her? I think not! :@@: I really don't understand why she's even mentioned in this context :p She doesn't deserve the critisism. She is a real musician and has only ever released her music independently without the help of a manager, record label or agent :thumbs:

http://www.jennybeck.co.uk

Overdose
12-30-2004, 07:17 PM
Christina for sure. she CAN sing. and has great lyrics.

Decka
12-30-2004, 11:16 PM
I finally agree with OD on something lol

Christina has a GREAT pipes, her voice range is incredible, she has been given a great talent and ability.

I like christina's voice, but i dislike what she tries to portray herself as. All skanky singers like her and spears have so much control over their image. At least Xtina shuts up about it. Here's Brittany's agenda......

1. Hire people to make slutty, revealing videos degrading yourself and advocating impulsive sex.

2. Speak out about how "misunderstood" you are and try to convice everyone that you are actually a good person. Go on talk shows and smile and try to become "innocent".

3. Make more music and videos about impulsive sex and being a slut.

And finally the latest one....Bitch about people "talking about you", when thats the only reason you are famous. Its certainly not because of her musical ability. Her voice isnt nearly as good as others. Its just that she doesn't have any modesty, and enjoys being revealing for idiots who only buy a cd because the girl is "hot"....

how do you know if you are this kind?

you bought the Lindsey Lohan "CD"......

LOL

elemental jim
12-31-2004, 08:21 PM
Excuse me..did you you say Britney was a 'good' singer ? Nah..
I do like watchin' her .. Early days in the pleated skirt..uh huh..
later in Toxic..Oh yeah baby(imagine Austin Powers impersonator)..
I'd like her to stand on her head and play pogo stick ..

Now for a truly fantastic voice.. Christina..(and also a pogo stick candidate)
Strong vocals and great range..
Christinas only POP competition is Amy Lee (Evanescence)

I dnk Jenny Beck..Went to her site..
http://www.jennybeck.co.uk/media.htm
nice, real nice..But like others said before not in the same style..hard to compare..
One thing for sure, she is a musician not just an entertainer or a pop princess..

BluMisterie
01-11-2005, 02:26 PM
I like Christina Aguilera the best. Her voice is really nice and pleasant to listen to. I also like the fact that she writes her own music--and she's a unique individual with a lot of things to say about our society today.

killthenite
01-20-2005, 02:14 PM
who the ef is Janny Black? And the others are just annoying and the same anyways, though I do give credit to Christina to actually having a good strong voice, and anyone that says she doesn't has a problem.

Win free band stuff at:
http://www.peta2.com/ot/o-midtown12-04.asp?c=26
http://www.peta2.com/ot/o-boysnightout.html?c=27

Moonbeam
06-14-2005, 03:43 PM
Jenny Beck sounds a bit like Jewel...and she plays guitar and writes all her own stuff. Christina does pen some great songs, but has Britney ever written a song?

revenG_DeSire
06-16-2005, 07:23 PM
Christina. She can sing, dance, AND cry! ^_^

friendly_seeker
06-26-2005, 01:30 AM
I use to like Britneys songs but now they are trash. Christina is really good. And I have never heard of Jenny Beck.

leela_zoid
08-01-2005, 08:34 PM
I prefer Avril Lavinge!:)

Evakian
08-01-2005, 10:00 PM
Christina Aguilera has more talent than the other two, but chooses more risque material in recent work.
The trophy in this case still goes to Christina regardless

autumnlullaby
09-05-2005, 12:40 PM
Well, I don't know who Jenny Beck is, but I think Christina is way better than Britney. Britney isn't that great of a singer. Christina has a good set of pipes, I just wish she'd use them to sing something besides trash. Honestly, I like Kelly Clarkson's vocals best. Not only can she sing very well, but she doesn't have to strip all her clothes off to get noticed.

Evakian
09-05-2005, 12:53 PM
Not only can she sing very well, but she doesn't have to strip all her clothes off to get noticed.

Well, regardless of the singing talent, their music is just not well made and realized. Britney's career is almost all based upon her personal life and foolish decisions, while we cannot say that for Christina who has dropped off the radar.
Mainly, they not only double their audience ;) by stripping, its pretty much all they do.