Ok who's watching? And who do you think may win? Where you diisappointed with the last cut? Tell me your thoughts>

I was upset that the Nikko glasses didn't make the last cut. The chunky guy was good but Nikko was better (in my opinion). As far as the gals go I like Carrie Underwood. And the black thin girl with the afro hair (I forget her name). I really don't care for Constantine. Bo is better.

I think in the end it will be more men in the finally.

I predict its going to come down to Bo Bice and Constantine...the two Rockers.

I am so glad that Mikalia got booted tonight. OMG her voice was horrid. And the attitude.........if she didn't get booted I was going to leave bad feedback on American Idol web site. What do ya think??

She didn't bug me that much, but I'm not going to miss her either. I'm just glad Nadia didn't get booted.

Bo is going all the way.

Originally posted by thoughts inside
she didn't get booted I was going to leave bad feedback on American Idol web site. What do ya think??

That would have gotten something done, I'm sure.

Originally posted by thoughts inside
she didn't get booted I was going to leave bad feedback on American Idol web site. What do ya think??

That would have gotten something done, I'm sure.

Originally posted by thoughts inside
I am so glad that Mikalia got booted tonight. OMG her voice was horrid. And the attitude.........if she didn't get booted I was going to leave bad feedback on American Idol web site. What do ya think?? Actually I thought she showed amazing grace under pressure...I think Paula could take a lesson or two from this kid.

As for her voice, I feel like they set her up for a fall. The kid was off key continually. How she made it as far as she did is beyond me...

And hopefully Paula learned you can't hit and run even if you are on American Idol...anyone want to bet on if she was stoned at the time.

My vote would be yes!

I agree.

She showed great character...and even smiled and thinked Simon for being honest and blunt with her.

As far as her voice goes........there were numerous people that got to the Hollywood rounds that could have easily beaten her. Not to mention the girl that was voted off the week prior to this one.

I just cant figure out how she lasted.

I am glad Mikalia went - she was terrible. That horrible accent - and she even sang with that accent (sang out of tune)

For some reason I wanted badly to see her crushed and in tears - she had that effect on me, I found her so irritating.

Kudos to her though, she's a young kid with a rosy future.

Originally posted by DrewM
I am glad Mikalia went - she was terrible. That horrible accent - and she even sang with that accent (sang out of tune)


My wife referred to her as "The Nanny" - as in Fran Drescher.

Originally posted by DrewM
I am glad Mikalia went - she was terrible. That horrible accent - and she even sang with that accent (sang out of tune)

For some reason I wanted badly to see her crushed and in tears - she had that effect on me, I found her so irritating.

Kudos to her though, she's a young kid with a rosy future.

Wow! Wasn't that a change of pace. Shes horrible--terrible--glad she was crying--wanted to see her crushed....SHE HAS A WONDERFUL FUTURE.

lol, wow.

Originally posted by jerejerebinks
Wow! Wasn't that a change of pace. Shes horrible--terrible--glad she was crying--wanted to see her crushed....SHE HAS A WONDERFUL FUTURE.

lol, wow.

Well yeah - I hated what I saw on TV - but I don't know her & heck she's 17 up in front of 60 million people - so you've got to cut her some slack.

Holy crapazoid...I think that Anwar has the most amazing spirit and projects really, really, well... but that voice....nah, he is all over the place. He doesn't stay in key or hit half the notes.

He is the male equivalent of Mikalia.

And I can't believe Scott has lasted this long... He looks like a serial killer...sorry but he does. And his voice is mediocre at best.

Bo, and Carrie and the other blonde and the babe with the Afro.... and maaaaaaybe Constantine...but he is if(y) too.

And Paula is making me craaaaaaaaaazy.

I can't watch the show straight through it is too painful.

Originally posted by ~Sal~
And Paula is making me craaaaaaaaaazy.

Paula has absolutely no purpose on that show what so ever. They need to ditch her and bring back Gene Simmons.

Originally posted by ~Sal~
I can't watch the show straight through it is too painful.

I never watch it live.

Paula really is worthless. No matter who sings - she says it's good.

Simon is pretty much always right. Sometimes he says crap people are good, but it's not very often he calls good people crap.

Whats up with Randy - all the yo yo dawg stuff - it's highly irritating.

I agree that scott looks a bit dangerous - serial killer fits the bill pretty well - maybe child molester works too.

How can that Bo guy ever have any credibility now in the real world? If he won - nobody would buy his records, and if he doesn't - he's that sell out pussy that went on Idol.

Constantine - never liked him much but he sang good tonight.

Whats up with trach surgery boy - he's really really bad.

Nicko is pretty good - but he won't win.

The black girl who sang last was pretty good tonight

Really Nadia seems about the best - but really none of them are that great. Compare them to Fantasia - now she was really good.

I thought Fatasia was horrible. Wonder why I havent heard anything else from her? Pretty sad that a half retarded chinese boy that went off on the first episode is more recognizable than her. lol.

Fantasia was an incredible singer. By far the most talented Idol winner to date.

I disagree. She annoyed me. Took everything over the top. I still think Clay Aiken was the most talented singer, while Kelly is the most marketable "Idol."

So you are one of those Clay fans huh :)

Originally posted by ~Sal~
Holy crapazoid...I think that Anwar has the most amazing spirit and projects really, really, well... but that voice....nah, he is all over the place. He doesn't stay in key or hit half the notes.

He is the male equivalent of Mikalia.

And I can't believe Scott has lasted this long... He looks like a serial killer...sorry but he does. And his voice is mediocre at best.

Bo, and Carrie and the other blonde and the babe with the Afro.... and maaaaaaybe Constantine...but he is if(y) too.

And Paula is making me craaaaaaaaaazy.

I can't watch the show straight through it is too painful.

He is not like Mikalia!!!! Its obvious he isn't gonna be the idol. But he does sing real good when he sings the slow stuff. And they all crack there voices now and then, Personally I think he's sexy.

What I was totally blown away by tonight was that Scott didn't get booted. He sucked. I think he thought he was gonna get booted, then he dosen't. Wonder how stupid he must feel when he knows he should have gotten booted and the other blonde (who by the way had an awesome voice) got bootd

Tonight was a shock

How Child Molester & throat op boy remain in the contest amazes me.

Maybe the will stay a few more weeks and end up like that Red headed crooner a few years back who stayed far longer than expected - he was wanting to get booted just to stop the death threats.

Who got booted? I had to work.

http://www.idolonfox.com/images/jessica-promo-d.jpg

Wow! Isn't she the one that Paula said was one of the ones to beat?

I don't think she was ever going to win it - but she could sing.

Unlike - Molester & Trach op boy - they are plain shite.

Her, Nadia & Anwar were in the bottom 3

Ok...

Who is molester and trach op boy?

And I cant stand Nadia or Anwar. I liked the two songs they sang this past week....but Nadia has an over the top personality, that God bless her, I know is her independence but just aggrivates me. And Anwar looks like the Alien from Alien.

Originally posted by jerejerebinks
Wow! Isn't she the one that Paula said was one of the ones to beat?

Yes. But she's also said that about the rest of them.

Originally posted by jerejerebinks
Ok...

Who is molester and trach op boy?

And I cant stand Nadia or Anwar. I liked the two songs they sang this past week....but Nadia has an over the top personality, that God bless her, I know is her independence but just aggrivates me. And Anwar looks like the Alien from Alien.

mmm. Seems like you don't like all the ones that actually have anything going for them. You didn't even like fantasia. Nadia is a natural.

Maybe if Britney Spears was in the competition you'd really know who to support :)

Originally posted by DrewM
Paula really is worthless. No matter who sings - she says it's good.

Simon is pretty much always right. Sometimes he says crap people are good, but it's not very often he calls good people crap.

Whats up with Randy - all the yo yo dawg stuff - it's highly irritating.

I agree that scott looks a bit dangerous - serial killer fits the bill pretty well - maybe child molester works too.

How can that Bo guy ever have any credibility now in the real world? If he won - nobody would buy his records, and if he doesn't - he's that sell out pussy that went on Idol.

Constantine - never liked him much but he sang good tonight.

Whats up with trach surgery boy - he's really really bad.

Nicko is pretty good - but he won't win.

The black girl who sang last was pretty good tonight

Really Nadia seems about the best - but really none of them are that great. Compare them to Fantasia - now she was really good.

Simon can be a real prick in his delivery but he is seldom wrong... His worst mistake to date was on Makalia... I don't know what the hell he saw in her...she was off key from her first note till her last note.

And yeah the yo dog shit is getting old... but then so is the whole interaction between the three of them. I wonder if Paula has had a night yet this season where she doesn't act like she is either stoned, or an imbecile. If she tells one more person she is "proud" of them I will vomit.

Trach boy has his ups and downs... He has a better than average voice but he is never going to be the Idol... he just doesn't cut it enough times.

I am not much for Nikko... he too has too many off nights.

I can't believe serial killer boy Scott made it through the week and what's her face got voted out... I thought she had one of the most powerful voices of any of them. But give Simon his due once again. He said she was unremarkable in that she was somewhat forgettable or not likable and that she had to work on that or go home...

Adiós to her... too bad because I actually really did enjoy listening to her without cringing.

As for Fantasia from last season... as this season painfully drags on Fantasia looks more and more as though she is in a whole league above these fools. The woman could SING without an error... period.

Originally posted by LionelHutz
My wife referred to her as "The Nanny" - as in Fran Drescher.

dead on...it was a nasal twang....

Originally posted by thoughts inside
Wonder how stupid he must feel when he knows he should have gotten booted and the other blonde (who by the way had an awesome voice) got bootd

He probably doesn't feel stupid at all... just lucky to have enough people to vote him alive... I say he is dead in the water by this coming week...

But then I would like to shot half of the rest of them...

Something's missing this season. Could be just me though. I get bored with repetition not just in this show but with everything... so could just be my perception.

I agree - none of them this season have much of a spark.

Last season - it was obvious that Fantasia was going to win. She put so much feeling into every song & as you say - she was consistent - always on the money.

Anyway - that blonde chick might be back, apparently serial killer boy is getting booted - he had undisclosed run in's with the law in the past

I've actually found this season a little more entertaining than usual. Not so much that the singers are any better, it just seems like they're picking more interesting songs. In all the past shows everyone just picks slow R&B songs. At least this year we've got the "rockers."

I've been a Constantine fan since the beginning and last night just gained him a million more fans. He was awesome. So is his band PRAY FOR THE SOUL OF BETTY! I just got their CD and it ROCKS!

GO CONSTANTINE & BETTY!!!

Constantine is definately the most improved. I thought he was the best last night.

Originally posted by DrewM
Constantine is definately the most improved. I thought he was the best last night.

Agreed..for last night...I still think Anwar sucks..but they like him. He has the charisma but for me, not the voice.

Tonight...fantasia is back...:))))

Last night was so damn boring. They need better themes.

Originally posted by LionelHutz
Last night was so damn boring. They need better themes.

Maybe the show is just wearing thin... maybe it was it just me being overly critical but um...Fantasia wasn't all that fantastic...lots of energy but... I was DISAPPOINTED!!!

She is boring. Energy cant make someone good. Pauly Shore has energy.........doesnt make him funny.

Close call for Bo last night, but Brocolli girl deserved to go.

Originally posted by jerejerebinks
Close call for Bo last night, but Brocolli girl deserved to go.

No way - the big fat guy and trach-boy both deserved to go first.

Originally posted by LionelHutz
No way - the big fat guy and trach-boy both deserved to go first.

Agreed - Nadia is probably one of the best in the show. She had emotion and style.

That fat guy - he's a moron. After he got thru he was punching the air & shouting - forgetting that 2 other contestants were still waiting. One of the other contestants had to tell him to quiet down.

It was a shock that Nadia went - she really was one of the best ones. She wipes the floor with fat guy & trach boy

Simon told her Tuesday that she would probably be going home. I think she was just too dry. This is not to say that the other two are good by any means...........in fact, I'm starting to buy into this season being less talented than others. I think Constantine has taken the reigns as the favorite though.

Constantine was amazing!!! I've been waiting for that performance from him!

Honestly...I didn't see it. He was last, and amazing race came on a little early or Idol was on a little late one. However..........everyone and everything I've seen said it was great. And Simon said it was astonishing....so it had to be ligit.

I can not believe that Nadia got sent home and Trach boy and serial killer are still there....

The woman can SING ... serial killer could not run to save his life if the studio were on fire...

Now I know that was a mean comment but come on the guy had better shed some major poundage or he won't see 30...

How the hell is he closer to being an American Idol than Nadia...

One would idolize WHAT??? He can't even stay in key, he can't move and he can't see! Yeah, that would be my goal if I were ten.

This is the most farcical year yet... and truly the whole thing is a sad... I know, I know.... but still please at least try to maintain some tiny, tiny sense of deception or reality...

This deteriorates weekly and it did not have far to fall from it's inception.

Anwar got sent home. He could sing but he would never went anywhere. Hes too unoriginal.

I am not a huge Bo fan by any means, but I loved what he did when Ryan asked him to stand by who he thought was the top. Perfect response.

Originally posted by jerejerebinks
I am not a huge Bo fan by any means, but I loved what he did when Ryan asked him to stand by who he thought was the top. Perfect response.

That was a crappy thing to ask him to do - I agree, he did the right thing.

I can't believe Scott and trach-boy are still in it.

Which one is trach boy??

Originally posted by jerejerebinks
Which one is trach boy??

Federov. I don't know his first name.

Originally posted by LionelHutz
Federov. I don't know his first name.

Anthony

My mom is watching AI from the UK - they get it at the weekend and they roll tues/wed into 1 show.

She asked me if I could get Anwars phone number because she thinks he's cute.

I didn't have the heart to tell her he was toast.

Its a bit of a joke this season. I think the voting is whacked - my wife tries to vote now and again & 9/10 she cannot get thru.

Did anyone notice that Paula's bizarre behavior has finally been noted publicly?

She denies being stoned and says it is because she has a rare neurological condition. So in my mind she is then stoned on prescribed drugs instead of designer drugs.

I was sorry to see Anwar go and I thought he would last longer than Scotty and Anthony but, the public is fickle.

Who the hell is keeping Scotty alive?????????????????

yeah Paula is really a nut job. I think Cowell will fire her end of this season. He seems bored & irritated with the whole thing & she seems to get on his last nerve most of the time.

Originally posted by DrewM
yeah Paula is really a nut job. I think Cowell will fire her end of this season. He seems bored & irritated with the whole thing & she seems to get on his last nerve most of the time.

Can he fire her????

Originally posted by ~Sal~
Can he fire her????

Sure, it's his show - he invented it & he owns it with a guy called Simon Fuller.

He gets a cut of the pie in everything - show advertsing, record sales of contestants.

Paula & Randy are just employees. Simon is the ultimate boss of the show. He also owns the UK show and licenses all the other Idol shows around the world. He is a very very rich man.

Originally posted by DrewM
Sure, it's his show - he invented it & he owns it with a guy called Simon Fuller.

He gets a cut of the pie in everything - show advertsing, record sales of contestants.

Paula & Randy are just employees. Simon is the ultimate boss of the show. He also owns the UK show and licenses all the other Idol shows around the world. He is a very very rich man.

Aah, my first learning lesson of the day. I had no idea.

I like the new young group he has put together that do opera... I think they released sometime this month. He will make another fortune off of them.

Originally posted by ~Sal~
Who the hell is keeping Scotty alive?????????????????

Apparently an extensive diet. :D

Originally posted by jerejerebinks
Apparently an extensive diet. :D

Ba...hahaha... <smack>

He actually looks like he is shedding, pounds that is, not hair.

All the running from his past perhaps?

...

funny

That scott guy seems to have a really bad attitude on the show.

I cannot understand why he is still there.

He'll be kicked off soon and go back to slamming the girlfriends head into the wall.

Rumour

I am uncertain of the accuracy but Friday morning on the radio I heard Scotty is being kept alive by a movement called "I hate American Idol". Apparently they band together to place votes for the one they deem 'most undesirable to win'. They have a website which I haven't found yet.

Now while I can see some irony in it, and even perhaps a bit of humor for a moment, they are actually being incredibly vicious in my estimate to those they vote for and for those who get tossed aside.

And speaking of Paula and her melt down on Thursday, she is now getting on my last nerve.

unlikely - they get 30+ million votes each week- it would have to be a big voting group.

Mind you - although I enjoy the show - I secretly hate it - I would be more than willing to join that group & see Scotty boy win.

Anybody hear about some petition signed by over 20,000 people to recount the votes, on the episode where Constantine was voted off?

Originally posted by silverbulletkc
Anybody hear about some petition signed by over 20,000 people to recount the votes, on the episode where Constantine was voted off?

No hadn't heard.

It's probably being led by Paula the sobber...:D